Dave does make a great point, and backs it up with precedent. I hope my comments aren’t viewed as argument. I don’t intend them in that way or a facebook I disagree manner at all. After reviewing the blogs on overturned revocations I too agree adjudicators mostly make the right call, and lean towards the applicant, as opposed to away. So I always tell those revoked to appeal. Much like the NFL rule of something substantially challenging a ruling on the field to invite overturning, balanced with the rule on what constitutes a catch…I would rather over report and be clear than risk accusation of under reporting, lack of candor, or needing to go through what this poor guy did to appeal. I am sure it caused a great deal of upheaval. Loss of revenue, etc. So in the end you could call him victorious on principle…did he really win? I am grateful to date those accepting my offer to assist in writing their appeal have clear cut cases of wrong doing they tried to hide. I need find the old link to the summaries of appeals to SOR’s. I enjoyed reading those. Very insightful to how much wiggle room a person has.